LUMA vs Franklin: Which Pickleball Paddle Is Right for You?
TL;DR — Franklin is one of the most recognisable sports equipment brands in the world and their C45 carbon fiber paddle series has made a strong mark on the competitive pickleball space — T700 carbon fiber applied at a 45-degree angle, double thermoformed construction, and USAP/UPA-approved, priced at ~$230. LUMA is built for intermediate to advanced players who want T700 carbon performance, original artwork on the face, and a paddle that stands out on court. If you're drawn to Franklin's thermoformed construction and pro athlete backing (including Anna Leigh Waters), the C45 is a serious paddle. If you want comparable T700 performance with genuine design identity and a price advantage, LUMA is the stronger choice.
The Brands at a Glance
Franklin Sports has been in the sporting goods business since 1946 — one of the oldest and most trusted equipment brands in America. Their entry into performance pickleball is more recent, but the C45 carbon fiber paddle series represents a genuine commitment to the competitive end of the market. Franklin has signed marquee athletes including Anna Leigh Waters, one of the most decorated players in professional pickleball, to play and develop their C45 paddle line. The brand's distribution is wide — available at Dick's Sporting Goods and major retailers in addition to their own channels — and the C45 has earned credible reviews in the competitive player community.
LUMA was purpose-built for a gap in the market: T700 carbon fiber performance paddles with original artwork design. Where Franklin brings mass-market brand recognition and a pro athlete development pipeline, LUMA brings a tight, specific focus — one performance-level paddle line, multiple designs, for players who want gear that performs and looks the part.
Head-to-Head: Where They Differ
Face Material & Application
Both brands use T700 carbon fiber. Franklin's C45 series applies T700 at a 45-degree peel-ply texture angle — a specific engineering choice designed to create consistent grit across the entire hitting surface, maximising spin potential. Independent testing puts the C45 at approximately 2,115 RPM spin output, which is solid without being market-leading. LUMA uses a standard T700 raw carbon face with proven grit texture for spin and control. Both are performing at the same material tier; the application method differs.
Core Construction
Franklin's C45 uses a double thermoformed unibody frame with dual foam channels — an outer perimeter foam that adds stability and a softer inner EVA foam layer. This is a Gen 3-style construction that adds pop and expands the sweet spot but has drawn some scrutiny for long-term durability in independent paddle teardowns. Specifically, some reviewers have noted edge delamination after extended use, though Franklin reports a less-than-1% defect rate. LUMA uses a polymer honeycomb core — a more traditional, proven construction method with a strong long-term durability record.
Performance Profile
The C45 14mm is fast and aggressive — feather-light swing weight (around 104) that suits net exchanges and speed-ups. The 16mm variant adds dwell time and control. Independent reviews consistently note the C45 is best suited to players who enjoy an attacking style and can manage the paddle's pop on touch shots. It's a specialised tool rather than a true all-court option. LUMA's polymer honeycomb build sits in the all-court space — balanced power and control for players who want consistency across all shot types.
Price
The Franklin C45 retails at approximately $230. LUMA is priced at $69.99. Depending on LUMA's final retail price, there may be a meaningful cost advantage — for comparable T700 face material and — without the thermoformed complexity and its associated durability questions.
Pro Backing
Franklin has Anna Leigh Waters — one of the sport's biggest names — developing and playing the C45 line. That pro backing carries real weight in the market and signals that the paddle performs at the highest level of competition. LUMA's positioning is not about pro athlete sponsorship; it's about the player who wants a performance paddle with a strong design identity. Different appeals, but both legitimate.
Design
Franklin's C45 paddles are well-designed in a conventional sense — clean, professional, competition-ready. LUMA's paddles carry original artwork on the face. For the player who uses their paddle as an expression of personality as much as a performance tool, LUMA has no direct competitor in this space.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| LUMA [Paddle Name] | Franklin C45 16mm | Franklin C45 14mm | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Face Material | T700 Carbon Fiber | T700 Carbon Fiber (45°) | T700 Carbon Fiber (45°) |
| Core | Polymer Honeycomb | Polymer + Dual Foam | Polymer + Dual Foam |
| Weight | 8oz | 7.6–8.0 oz | 7.5–7.9 oz |
| Core Thickness | 16mm | 16mm | 14mm |
| Swing Weight | 116 | 116 | 104 |
| Price | $69.99 | ~$230 | ~$230 |
| Construction | T700 Carbon Fiber | Double Thermoformed | Double Thermoformed |
| Design Options | Standard | Standard | Standard |
| Warranty | Limited | 1-Year Limited | 1-Year Limited |
Who Should Buy Which
Buy Franklin C45 if: You want a thermoformed performance paddle with pro athlete development behind it, you play an aggressive attacking style and want the fast, poppy feel of the 14mm, or you want dual USAP/UPA certification for the widest competition eligibility. Franklin's brand presence and retail availability are also practical advantages for players who want easy access and confidence in the name.
Buy LUMA if: You want T700 carbon fiber performance with a more balanced all-court profile, you value a paddle with original artwork and design identity, or you're drawn to a brand built specifically around pickleball performance rather than a wider sports equipment catalogue. LUMA's polymer core construction also offers a more traditional, proven durability profile compared to thermoformed foam-channel builds.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Franklin C45 better than LUMA? At the face material level, both use T700 carbon fiber — the standard for serious competitive play in 2026. The C45's 45-degree application creates a specific, consistent texture that generates strong spin. LUMA's T700 face delivers comparable grit and spin performance. Where they diverge is construction (thermoformed vs. polymer core), performance profile (C45 skews attacking, LUMA is more all-court), and design — LUMA wins clearly on the latter. Neither is objectively better; it depends on play style.
How durable is the Franklin C45? Franklin reports a less than 1% defect rate and stands behind the paddle with a one-year warranty. However, independent reviewers have documented edge delamination issues in some units after extended testing — specifically, the foam channel construction disbonding from the edge in a small number of cases. This is a known Gen 3 construction risk across multiple brands, not unique to Franklin. For most players, the C45 performs without issue within its warranty period. LUMA's polymer core construction has no equivalent documented concerns.
Does Franklin C45 have better spin than LUMA? Independent lab testing puts the C45 at approximately 2,115 RPM — respectable but not market-leading in 2026. LUMA's T700 raw carbon face generates competitive spin at the standard performance level. The 45-degree application angle on the C45 creates a very consistent surface texture, which some players find improves spin shot reliability. For most intermediate players, both paddles generate more spin than their technique currently requires.
Is Franklin a good pickleball brand? Franklin has strong brand credibility built over 75+ years in sporting goods and has invested seriously in pickleball through pro athlete partnerships and the C45 line. Their entry-level and mid-range paddles are well-regarded. The C45 is their most performance-focused product and sits credibly in the competitive player space.
Who plays with Franklin paddles professionally? Anna Leigh Waters — widely regarded as one of the best pickleball players in the world — signed with Franklin in early 2026 and has been playing and developing the C45 line. That endorsement carries genuine credibility in competitive circles.
Sources & References
- USA Pickleball — Approved Equipment List: usapickleball.org/play/equipment-standards/
- Franklin Sports — C45 Series: franklinsports.com/c45-carbon-fiber-paddle-series
- Pickleball Effect — Franklin C45 Review: pickleballeffect.com/equipment-reviews/franklin-c45-review-weight-set-up-analysis/
- JohnKew Pickleball — C45 Dynasty & Tempo Review: johnkewpickleball.com/franklin-c45
- The Kitchen — Best Pickleball Paddles 2026: thekitchenpickle.com/blogs/gear/best-pickleball-paddles-available
- r/Pickleball — Franklin C45 Community Discussion: reddit.com/r/Pickleball
Decided on LUMA? → Shop LUMA Paddles